Article
Art by Doug Cushman

The Missing Pumpkin Pie

Can you solve the Thanksgiving mystery?

By Doug Cushman
From the October/November 2025 Issue

Learning Objective: Students will discuss elements of mystery stories and identify them in a fiction story.

Lexiles: 490L

My name is Gaston LeGrande, detective and chef.

Yesterday I was on my way to get marshmallows for my
best dish. Gilda Goose ran out of her hat shop.

“Gaston!” she called. “My pumpkin pie has been stolen.”

“Give me the facts,” I said.

“I baked my pie this morning,” said Gilda. “Then I set it out in the hat shop to show my helper, Sally!” 

“What happened next?” I said. 

“I left the pie and went to get some new ribbons,” Gilda said. “When I got back, the pie was gone. And tomorrow is Thanksgiving!”

“Does Sally like sweets?” I said. 

“I don’t know,” said Gilda.

“I love a delicious mystery,”
I said. “I will look for clues.”

Inside the shop, there were hats of all kinds. 

“You have very unusual hats,” I said. 

“I design them all,” said Gilda.

My chef’s nose smelled sugar and pumpkin spice. The smells were from an empty hat stand. 

Then I saw some crumbs on the floor. A clue!

“These look like pie crumbs,” I said. 

Just then Sally came in.

“Miss Gilda!” she said. “I was just in the back counting the money. I sold one of your best hats today!”

“That is nice,” said Gilda. “But we are busy with a mystery.”

A trail of crumbs led to the door.

Suddenly, I began to see the answer to the mystery.

“Follow that trail,” I said.

The crumbs stopped at the home of Madame LaBelle. She was coming out.

“My dear Gilda!” said Madame LaBelle. “Everyone just loves my new hat!”

“It is a good hat,” I said. “But it is a better dessert!”

“You are wearing my pumpkin pie!” said Gilda.

“It looked like a new design,” said Sally. “So I glued on a ribbon and sold it.”

“Mystery solved,” I said. “Now to get my marshmallows.” 

“That gives me an idea for a new hat,” said Gilda.

“Not so fast,” I said. “I think my marshmallows belong in my belly and not on my head.”

video (1)
Activities (3)
Answer Key (1)
video (1)
Activities (3) Download All Quizzes and Activities
Answer Key (1)

About the Story

English Language Arts Focus

Genre

Step-by-Step Lesson Plan

Implementation

  • Whole group

Pairings and Text Connections

Before-Reading Resources

  • Video: What is a Mystery? (5 minutes) Use this video to introduce students to the elements of a mystery story.

Suggested Reading Focus

Genre (20 minutes)

  • For the first reading, focus on comprehension and enjoyment. Read the story aloud while students follow along in their magazines. Model summarizing each section and asking comprehension questions at each Pause and Think. Summarize the events of the story.
  • For the second reading, encourage students to think about what makes “The Missing Pumpkin Pie” a mystery story. When you’re done reading, prompt them to discuss the mystery elements. What are they searching for? What are the clues? How do they solve the mystery?

After-Reading Skills Practice

  • Skills: story elements; writing (15 minutes)

Text-to-Speech